A Brief Review of "The Hobbit"

     I was fortunate enough to be able to see "The Hobbit" yesterday; and I enjoyed it very much.  As with all movies, there were definite pros and cons, of course, and it is these that I would like to discuss briefly.
     I shall start, I think, with the pros.  The music, scenery, and most of the casting were brilliant.  Howard Shore is truly a genius; the dwarves' song, which serves as the man theme for the whole film, is perfect, and the many other themes are beautiful as well.  The scenery is simply gorgeous (I need not say more).  The actors who played Bilbo, Thorin & Co., Gandalf, and Galadriel were excellent.  The actor who played Elrond was, through no fault of his own, not quite perfect.  His voice is just what comes to mind of when I think of Elrond, but his physical appearance is, in my mind at least, not quite right.
     Now for the cons of the movie.  The two main things that irritated me were these: 1.  Tolkien's book is a children's story, a charming tale of adventure.  The movie has lost this charm, and is simply an epic fantasy action film, though a good one.  2.  The decision to make "The Hobbit" into a trilogy is quite annoying to me.  I can understand making two movies, but three, I think, crosses a line.  It is a decision made simply to make more money, which is rather ironic, seeing as the story deals much with dwarves and their love of gold.
     Another thing that bothered me was that, although many lines from the book were used in the film, the filmmakers did not follow the plot of the book very closely.  There were parts that were practically unchanged, but there were other parts that were completely invented.  For example, one of the major plot lines of the film has to do with the orc Azog, who was never mentioned in The Hobbit.  (For more information on Azog, see The Return of the King, Appendix A, pp. 441-443.)
     There were other small details that were wrong, but also many that were right.  I have spent more time discussing the cons than the pros, but the pros do not need to be talked over and picked through.  It suffices merely to say that all the pros were excellent pros, and that "The Hobbit" was a very good movie that I enjoyed very much.

Another Quote

     By now, you can probably tell that I am very fond of quotes.  Perhaps a little too fond, if that is indeed possible.  Regardless, I have another quote that I would like to share--a passage from Antoine de Saint Exupery's The Little Prince (which is, by the way, a delightful little book).  I think that it is quite charming and, at the same time, thought-provoking.

     "Grown-ups love figures.  When you tell them that you have made a new friend, they never ask you any questions about essential matters.  They never say to you, "What does his voice sound like?  What games does he love best?  Does he collect butterflies?"  Instead, they demand: "How old is he?  How many brothers does he have?  How much does he weigh?  How much money does his father make?"  Only from these figures do they think they have learned anything about him . . . They are like that.  One must not hold it against them.  Children should always show great forbearance towards grown-up people."
                                                                                                                        ~Antoine de Saint Exupery

   

An Inspiring Quote

     I have recently been reading a charming collection of letters from C. S. Lewis to children.  As I have been reading, I have come across a number of very good quotes, but I especially enjoyed this one.

     "Remember that there are only three kinds of things anyone need ever do.  (1) Things we ought to do (2) Things we've got to do (3) Things we like doing."
                                                                                                 ~C. S. Lewis